|
Results of sputum cytology in bronchogenic carcinoma--a
correlation with patient survival.Gan
No Rinsho. 1984 Aug;30(10):1235-40.
In a study of
65 of patients with bronchogenic carcinoma who had thoracotomy over
a 5-year period, cytodiagnosis by 3-day consecutive sputum cytology
was reported positive for malignant cells in 55.4%. Data analysis
revealed that the overall cytodiagnosis correlated with clinical
stage, tumor size, site of origin, topography and histologic types.
From the histologic standpoint, the site of origin was significantly
related to the positive cytology in patients with squamous cell
carcinoma among factors influencing the results of sputum cytology.
On the other hand, there was a correlation of tumor size and the
positive cytology in patients with adenocarcinoma. In addition, poor
prognosis related to the positive cytology in adenocarcinoma cases
in terms of the relationship between the results through sputum
examination and survival. The authors emphasized that sputum
cytology has proven to be a valuable factor for determining
prognosis, especially in patients with adenocarcinoma
Factors
significant in the diagnostic accuracy of lung cytology in bronchial
washing and sputum samples. I. Bronchial washings.Acta
Cytol. 1983 Jul-Aug;27(4):391-6
Some factors
influencing the diagnostic accuracy for primary lung cancer in
bronchial washings were studied in 276 consecutive cases seen
between 1959 and 1974. Diagnostic accuracy increased during the
years under study; the reasons included increasing expertise of the
laboratory staff, better documentation of cytologic criteria and
improved collection techniques. The overall accuracy was 74%.
Detection of malignant cells was highest for squamous-cell and
adenosquamous carcinomas (81%), small-cell carcinoma, adenocarcinoma
and large-cell carcinoma (70%) and lowest for bronchioloalveolar-cell
carcinoma (47%). Accuracy was 84% for central tumors as compared to
30% for peripheral lesions. Tumors of less than 2 cm in diameter
yielded very poor results (15%) while those greater than 2 cm
yielded 82% accuracy. The specificity of diagnosis of cell type in
those specimens with malignant cells was over 93% for squamous-cell
carcinoma, small-cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma, 77% for
large-cell carcinoma and below 50% for adenosquamous carcinoma,
bronchioloalveolar carcinoma and the uncommon tumors. Two bronchial
washings per case gave an appreciably better result (92%) than one
per case (68%). The percentage of unsatisfactory specimens from
those with cancer was 13.5 and from a control group was 29.9.
Reasons for unsatisfactory specimens included limited cellular
material, excessive blood and/or leukocytes and drying artifacts.
Lung cancer
cell type as a determinant of bronchoscopy yield.Chest.
1983 Oct;84(4):428-30.
The accuracy
of diagnosis of lung cancer obtained by fiberoptic bronchoscopy
utilizing sputum cytology and bronchial biopsy depends on the size,
location, and number of biopsy samples taken from the tumor. We have
found that the accuracy of diagnosis also depends upon the
histologic type of cancer. Fiberoptic bronchoscopy (brushings,
washing, and biopsies) was performed and sputum cytology and
bronchial tissue was obtained from 51 patients with histologically-proven
lung cancer. The bronchial biopsy was more sensitive than the
bronchial washing and brushing techniques in detecting primary
bronchogenic and metastatic carcinoma. It was positive in ten of ten
patients with small cell carcinoma, 12 out of 20 cases of squamous
cell carcinoma, three of four cases of adenocarcinoma, and three of
four patients with large cell cancer. The bronchial biopsy yield was
influenced by the histologic cell type with the highest diagnostic
yield being found with small cell carcinoma
Effect of
methods of sample taking on the cytologic diagnosis of lung tumors.
Acta
Cytol. 1978 Sep-Oct;22(5):425-30
By the
evaluation of unselected cytologic specimens taken by different
methods, the possible effect of sampling on the cytologic diagnosis
was analyzed. A statistically significant tendency was established
for certain tumors to be better diagnosed by certain methods of
sampling. In order of the increasing radicality of the method, the
following significant coincidences were found and discussed: Sputum
for the diagnosis of bronchialalveolar cell carcinoma and epidermoid
carcinoma (cornified cells); Bronchial washing for oatcell
(undifferentiated) carcinoma and epidermoid carcinoma (moderately
cornified cells); Bronchial brushing for epidermoid carcinoma (not
cornified cells) and large cell (undifferentiated) carcinoma;
Transthoracal needle aspiration for polymorphic carcinoma and
metastasis; and Pleural effusion for the diagnosis of metastasis,
bronchogenic adenocarcinoma and mesothelioma. If the clinical
features indicate a certain tumor type, the data give evidence that
it is advantageous to adjust the method of sample taking to the
expected tumor type as far as possible. In the case of necessary
re-examinations, transthoracic needle aspiration and bronchial
brushing should especially be used, in addition to the self-evident
examination of material produced spontaneously, i.e., sputum and
pleural effusion, because of the relatively high expected value of
these methods for positive diagnoses in re-examinations.
|